Regarding Alanna McDonalds
(sister worker) letter to the overseers
in New
Brunswick Canada
2023
The
letter
This is very well written and detailed letter about
life in the work for a sister worker ... quite bluntly describing
many of the problems women workers have in an extreme male
authoriterian culture. Also describing a culture of direct
abuse
The following are 22 comments on Wings For Truth from
different folks expressing clear understanding and support for
Alanna through the direct persecution she is suffering from
seniors in the ministry.
Comment #20 |
Comment #21 |
Comment #22 |
henoffour | August
2, 2023 at 8:00 am
Alanna, thank you for being
honest about things, your courage will be a help to
others. But, if workers/ministers aren’t bringing the
Spirit of Peace/God into people’s homes (and everywhere
they go), because they aren’t reading and praying for
God’s help…I doubt a handbook/pamphlet will have much
affect. I think it will be used more as a weapon against
each other than anything. They aren’t showing the "love
of Christ one to another", nor are they adhereing to
scripture like Ephesians 5 that NONE of this would be
even ONCE named amongst us. But, these are just my
thoughts. |
Edgar Massey | August
7, 2023 at 9:40 am
I am surprized at the lack of
interest shown in the seemingly moral melt down in NB
with the unwillingness to deal with serious abuse
allegations (albeit not CSA) — Instead we seem to see
the "whistle blower punishment syndrome" that we
recognize so well in other Canadian fields
|
henoffour | August
16, 2023 at 7:11 pm
Thank you Alanna, for speaking
out. I have been on the ugly end of abuse by the sister
workers (I am not a worker, but my brother was for 15
years, and for some reason I’m guessing some felt I was
fair game because he was in the work). I have also seen
workers abusing their companions…but, only the sister
workers doing it. The men are more sneaky/devious. So,
this whole issue begs: How is this "Showing LOVE one TO
another"? So that they whole world will know that WE are
HIS? How is this bringing the Spirit of Peace into
people’s homes? (and wherever they are). It’s
sickening!! I’m not in Canada, but most of my family
lives up there. I’m in the USA. Not any better here.
|
|
|
|
Comment #18 |
Comment #19 |
Comment #19 |
Edgar Massey | May
30, 2023 at 8:05 am
I find it interesting that
there has been so little follow up on this letter … It
was amazingly courageously and truthfully written. Maybe
there have been reactions … just me that haven’t heard
about it!
|
No confidence in the ministry | July
8, 2023 at 2:34 am
Edgar, I am familiar with
Alanna. While in her area there are people who are
standing up for her, I have heard very little from any
friend or worker in other areas.
This letter should bring a
public outcry,( meaning among the friends). I have
spoken and written to a few and am totally devastated by
their lack of ………… no words.
Many feel God will take care of it, which of course He
will in time, but hardly anyone is openly taking a stand
for righteousness.
Alanna said, we need your help.
Sadly, we are failing her and others.
I am praying that GOD will
show us a way to help.
I am so disappointed that people are just looking the
other way, waiting for someone else to make a move.
Overseers and many workers are
a big part of the problem.
While I have loved the fellowship, it sure seems to be a
haven for perverted and disturbed people.
I encourage all to pray
earnestly, fervently, incessantly and unceasingly that
God would come to our aid.
|
Sara Wojcik | July
20, 2023 at 4:48 pm
Thank you, Alanna, for your
courage and strength in speaking the truth about your
experience and your observations in the work. Pressure
from other friends and workers has been a powerful
deterrent to voicing the truth about these issues.
Finally, people are realizing that these people have
power over us, ONLY if we give it to them. God would
never give power to people who use and abuse others, so
we know their power is not from God, but self-assumed.
We all need to stand up and do what the Holy Spirit
moves upon us to do! Thank you again, for being a brave
example!
|
|
|
|
Comment #16 |
Comment #17 |
Holly Theede | April
27, 2023 at 8:08 am
The DSM5, Diagnostic and
Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, is a valuable
tool . There is a section on Personality Disorders;
Narcissistic , Histrionic, Antisocial, Borderline
Personality Disorders. Trust me, anyone can read and
understand this manual.
Personality disorders are thought to have a genetic
component, however, expression of the disorder is
definitely influenced by how the individual was parented
and the individual’s experiences growing up. If a child
has too restrictive or shame based parenting , then they
struggle to make decisions in line with developmental
milestones. This results in that child learning to
manipulate or lie to others to have any independence.
What is the atmosphere in the "strict" professing
family? I grew up with TV is evil rather than , we
should watch , read etc that which is good , true or
beautiful.
If a child grows up without much guidance/parenting at
all, then the child struggles to feel safe because
children need help in making decisions and learn
boundaries.
Too much or too little "parenting " and the kind of
parenting, shame based vs loving guidance will affect
the adult personality.
I definitely was easy prey for a covert spiritual
narcissist ( he told me so too when he received divorce
papers) because I was conditioned to believe I was
responsible for my own behavior and God would deal with
the abuser if I prayed enough. How many workers have
prayed for their abusive co worker to be a nice person?
Healthy boundaries and not allowing satan deceive is not
preached, but rather, tolerance of evil is encouraged.
satan knows the Bible so remember to stay away from
someone who is not living a loving way.
Les Carter phD has very well done youtube videos on
Narcissism. They are free and valuable. We can improve
our parenting to be aware of how we may influence our
children.
There are videos on how to parent so you don’t raise a
narcissist. We can learn how to set boundaries so those
with personality disorders can’t hurt us.
We must do better! These abusive workers likely have
developed personality disorders and the abuse is being
tolerated. sad.
|
Ken Baker | May
4, 2023 at 1:47 pm
Hi Alana I believe everything
you wrote , I feel so sorry for you and Morgan your both
in my thoughts and prayers
|
|
|
|
Comment #14 |
Comment #15 |
Benjamin Jacques | April
27, 2023 at 7:20 am
Thank you. We need complete
honesty openness and we need to be strong in faith and
love meekness and gentleness but that does not mean we
do not deal with wrong amongst us with passiveness. Paul
is clear on this that those that are able to rightly
execute the word and are sensitive to the leading of the
spirit should be taking a strong stand for what is right
and separating ourselves as a little leaven leaveneth
the whole lump as Paul says. Also it is clear there has
been a lack within oversight as Paul and Peter and the
other faithful servants and elders and disciples met
when there were things to discuss together and made
decisions about the kingdom together. No one person or
select group should decide anything about gods kingdom
as there must be unity in the spirit and no one is to
lord over another. I hope this will begin a cleansing of
the kingdom of rules that are man made and not of the
spirit, and lead into deeper fellowship love and unity
within the kingdom by everyone taking care to their own
spirit and condition and being vigilant in our privilege
to carry the name of Jesus. If we say we follow the
bible then that is what we ought to do. There is clear
direction on how to handle the affairs of the kingdom.
The spirit also provides direction. It says when there
are concerns that must be brought forward bring them to
the church that means the whole church which is not a
person or small group of overseers or workers. This is
never mentioned in the bible and therefore not
scriptural.
This reminds me of Gods people
in the Old Testament wanting a king. The human nature
likes this approach for some reason maybe it allows us
to not take responsibility for the condition of the
kingdom. If we want to the kingdom to be united then
united we must stand and be willing to act upon the
direction of the spirit even when it seems like no
others are standing. Be strong in faith let gods spirit
lead.
|
asisterwhocares | April
29, 2023 at 5:04 pm
So sad to read this young
worker, Allana, talk about what she has endured from
companions and coworkers. My dad said his older brother,
just a young man himself, told an older sister worker
that the younger sister hadn’t gone into the work to be
a slave to older "servants"! There have been false
accusations made, too, with the innocent persons trying
to get the workers to meet with the accuser as is
scriptural but being ignored by the workers. This double
life is like the Pharisees, whited sepulchers. And
wearing costumes and buns to look like the 50s is
certainly not scriptural but most women are afraid to
buck the rules. Fear based compliance rather than loving
service isn’t scriptural either. We have to do better.
|
|
|
|
Comment #11 |
Comment #12 |
Comment #13 |
Andrew Jacques | May
2, 2023 at 5:25 am
"Now what are we going to do?"
This question has been risen
by many and often.
Friends and workers.
I will live by faith. I will take the question "now what
are we going to do about it?" and bring it to God! Find
an answer and do that in my life and my little area of
impact.
Jesus is my overseer.
The spirit is my guide.
And love is the law.
We walk only the way, life and
light of Jesus and these three of no other leader.
|
Doreen Saunders | July
8, 2023 at 2:57 am
Hello Andrew, so good to see
you here, encouraging Alanna. Your comments are
encouraging, there is only one overseer, the ministry
has gotten sidetracked.
I wondered so many times Andrew, why you left the work.
I enjoyed having you in our home sooo much.
You told me once that you loved being in our home, it
was lovely to hear that.
I wish you all the best my dear Andrew.
Thank you for standing against
these atrocities, for calling the workers out on it, (
many people didn’t and don’t yet know )
😳For
taking this to God and being determined to make an
impact in your own little area.
Loving your neighbour as yourself.
|
asisterwhocares | April
29, 2023 at 5:04 pm
So sad to read this young
worker, Allana, talk about what she has endured from
companions and coworkers. My dad said his older brother,
just a young man himself, told an older sister worker
that the younger sister hadn’t gone into the work to be
a slave to older "servants"! There have been false
accusations made, too, with the innocent persons trying
to get the workers to meet with the accuser as is
scriptural but being ignored by the workers. This double
life is like the Pharisees, whited sepulchers. And
wearing costumes and buns to look like the 50s is
certainly not scriptural but most women are afraid to
buck the rules. Fear based compliance rather than loving
service isn’t scriptural either. We have to do better.
|
|
|
|
Comment #10 |
Comment #11 |
Andrew Jacques | April
27, 2023 at 5:30 am
Thank you so much Alanna.
I would like to say that your
professional and personal approach to this letter is
beautiful.
What a powerfully written
letter. Thank you, thank you and thank you for your
courage, grace, Persistence, and astounding bravery.
I call all the workers out for
their complicit behaviour in the lack of transparency
and false belief of "fitting in."
To all the workers I
recommended: look at Alanna and others who are being
wise and full of the spirit and sharing the truth.
Facing Hurts and fears will
always be much Better than false securities.
To me and all: let us take the
verse we read this morning, and apply it with the help
of the spirit.
The ONLY overseer is Jesus.
The ONLY law is love.
The ONLY guide is the spirit.
Thanks again Alanna. Wow.
Thanks to all who love and encourage an honest answer.
|
Holly Theede | April
27, 2023 at 7:35 am
Yes, this letter definitely
applies to everyone. Divorce is shunned and too often I
have heard stories of workers telling women to stay
married to the abuser. Our fellowship is the perfect
fellowship for abusers to find free will to abuse. How
many times have we heard how a spouse lived in abuse
until the abusive spouse finally professed and then all
was right! What father would want his children abused ?
This is not love.
What is the man’s name who committed suicide after being
told he could not take part in meeting after he
remarried? |
|
|
|
Comment #9 |
Comment #10 |
Comment #11 |
Karen R Taylor | April
26, 2023 at 7:33 am
Alanna, I thank you for your
amazing courage. I support you in any way you need. Most
of all…I Believe you. |
Louise | April
27, 2023 at 6:36 am
Yes these workers need to know
we support them but how do we get the message out?
I am not part of the meetings but willing to help as I
told a brother worker yesterday. |
Kay | April
26, 2023 at 8:28 am
Thinking of you and Morgan and
hope that overseers wake up to this sorrow. It is adult
abuse and not just children…victims of all ages have
suffered this sorrow. |
|
|
|
Comment #7 |
Comment #8 |
Sharon Dutchak | July
21, 2023 at 12:50 pm
One day I will. My story is
long as well
Have to gather my thoughts and feelings together before
I do |
Nadine | April
25, 2023 at 10:58 am
This letter resonates with my
soul, after having loved ones in the work and witnessing
how new young workers have been treated so poorly in our
home by their older co-laborers everything this woman
has said is true and it has Distressed us for SO LONG.
Since the Dean Bruer story broke I have heard people say
"well sister workers wouldn’t do that" in my mind a
screaming voice has resounded over and over that SOME
sister workers I’ve interacted with and have witnessed
how they treated their companions are some of the
meanest, most vindictive humans alive and I am not sure
how they can even call themselves servants of God
because they are NOT living it. Allana, if you ever get
to see this, your bravery, and courage is amazing. Many
just have to step away because the abuse is intolerable
and then they are told they didn’t pray enough etc etc.
The only thing that brings me comfort in all of it is
God sees the whole picture and these individuals will be
dealt with some day if they are not here on earth.
It seems some workers act as
though it is a "right of PASSAGE" to treat their
companions poorly because they withstood it when they
were young. What a horrible cycle. I pray change is on
the way, we don’t need workers, male or female. that are
tyrants, or dictators, who cut a swath with their swords
of tyranny and rules we need HUMBLE servants full of
love, and kindness and hearts like Jesus that are
fishers of men. Please know you’re in our prayers Allana.
|
|
|
|
Comment #4 |
Comment #5 |
Comment #6 |
Mike Eblen | April
22, 2023 at 6:51 pm
Thanks Alanna, I appreciate
you, and I’m very sorry for what happened to you! Yes,
it’s way past time for the abuse to stop! I believe
changes will, and are, being made. With Gods help, true
commitment and honesty, we will make it a safe place!
With Brotherly Love,
Mike Eblen |
Not sayin | July
7, 2023 at 8:16 pm
This is an authentic letter
from an authentic worker. Absolutely
|
Louise | April
25, 2023 at 4:10 am
Thanks Deborah.I wish more
workers will come forward regarding all kinds of abuse.
Emotional abuse is just more difficult to recognize, I
only realized recently that what I experienced myself
from a elder and his wife was infact emotional abuse and
it had a effect on me.With God we can heal but it is a
long road and feels so unfair and unnessasary.
|
|
|
|
Comment #1 |
Comment #2 |
Comment #3 |
Debbie Kent | April
22, 2023 at 4:56 am
Thank you for writing this
letter. My siblings were abused by workers in the ‘60’s
and ‘70’s and no one believed them. My mom also spoke of
sexual abuse as a child by workers in her dying days.
Unfortunately three of my siblings have prematurely
passed due to unhealthy lifestyles that stemmed from
this abuse, the pain and shame were overwhelming! Again
thanks, but too late for my family.
|
Not sayin right now | July
7, 2023 at 8:13 pm
Hi there, Alana is a worker
right now, under a lot of pressure no doubt and shunning
as well. She was in our field .
Read your account years ago, am thankful for it 😊
|
MASSEY EDGAR | July
7, 2023 at 8:43 pm
Thanks for your answer to my question. I could worry
about the long term pressure on her … In one sense it
could be regarded as courageous to be open about her
concerns. … Yet, from what I understand about the
Bainbridge situation positive change is unlikely and her
position as it is could easily become unlivable without
mental damage. Thanks again for your reply
|
|